Cafe 2825

Nestled in the heart of Atlantic City, Cafe 2825 is a quintessential Italian restaurant that invites you to experience authentic Mediterranean flavors with an elevated twist. This charming gem at 2825 Atlantic Ave charmed diners with its impeccable commitment to tradition, blending classic recipes with fresh, artisanal ingredients to create an unforgettable culinary journey.

Step inside and you’re immediately transported to an Italian trattoria where rustic elegance meets warm hospitality. The ambiance is intimate yet vibrant, perfect for everything from romantic dinners to lively family gatherings. What truly sets Cafe 2825 apart is their spectacular tableside service — an artful performance that transforms dining into an interactive experience. Imagine watching a Caesar salad come alive right before your eyes or witnessing pasta being expertly tossed in a smoky cheese wheel infused with truffle richness.

The menu reads like an homage to Italy’s rich culinary heritage. Start with captivating old-school appetizers such as the Spicy Stuffed Calamari — tender calamari tubes filled with crab and savory breadcrumbs swimming in a zesty marinara — or the fire-charred Marinated Octopus paired with roasted potatoes and silky avocado purée. For pasta lovers, the Cacio e Pepe with mushrooms is a must-try, as is the decadently creamy Pasta in Cheese Wheel blended tableside with black truffle cheese, adding earthy depth to each bite.

Entrees at Cafe 2825 demonstrate true Italian mastery. The Veal Chop Parmigiana is generously breaded and perfectly executed, while the Veal Rollatini Alla Tiana offers a delicate balance of flavors wrapped in tender veal. Meat enthusiasts will find themselves indulging in the Porterhouse Steak Caprese or savoring the perfectly braised Ossobuco. For seafood aficionados, the luxurious 2 Lobster Tails with Shrimp and Scallops present a sumptuous oceanic feast. Every dish is layered with rich, comforting flavors that evoke cherished family recipes — a sentiment echoed by multiple patrons who describe feeling like they’ve been transported back to Italy or their grandmother’s kitchen.

Don’t overlook the dessert offerings, which provide the perfect sweet finale. The Coconut Cheesecake and classic Tiramisu carry just the right balance of creaminess and decadence, while the Blueberry Cheesecake bursts with freshness that cleanses the palate.

Complement your meal with a carefully curated bottle from Joe’s Bottle Picks, including a 2016 Corvina Tommasi 'Ripasso' with notes of dried berries and floral complexity or a crisp Chardonnay from Napa Valley’s Stags Leap winery. Both pair beautifully with the diverse flavors on the menu, enhancing your dining pleasure.

But it’s not just the food — the customer reviews speak volumes about the full experience. Laurie Newton recalls feeling “back in time eating in Italy” and insists on making reservations early to enjoy the highly recommended tableside service. Rebecca Rementer, craving authentic Sunday gravy, found her memories perfectly mirrored in the dishes served, praising the standout Cacio e Pepe and handmade mozzarella. Allison K highlights the outstanding freshness of the cheeses and the memorable meatballs, while Matt Davies encourages diners not to miss the mozzarella and cheese wheel pasta, summarizing the experience as “life is good.” Jordan Kaufman also celebrates the top-notch quality, particularly the tableside mozzarella.

Cafe 2825 epitomizes Italian dining at its finest—a blend of soulful cooking, exceptional service, and an atmosphere rich with tradition and warmth. If you are in Atlantic City craving a genuine Italian meal that’s as emotionally resonant as it is delicious, this restaurant deserves a prime spot on your itinerary.

Contact: +1 609-344-6913 | Location: 2825 Atlantic Ave, Atlantic City, NJ 08401